Case study · Selling in Southlake
How I sold a renovated home in Southridge Lakes for $150,000 over asking, with no comps to go on.
In June 2023, my sellers’ home in Southridge Lakes in Southlake had been renovated to a level no other home in the neighborhood had reached, and no home there had sold for more than about $1.25 million. We listed at $1,399,999, launched with an open house that brought more than 100 people through the door, and closed at $1,550,000, the highest sale in the neighborhood at the time.

The situation
Who were the sellers, and why were they selling?
The sellers’ eldest child graduated from Carroll Senior High School and they decided to move out of the area.
Why was there no clear price for this home?
The renovation set this home apart. No other home in Southridge Lakes had been renovated to the same extent, so there were no true comparable sales to point to.
The neighborhood also had a ceiling. At the time, no home in Southridge Lakes had sold for more than about $1.25 million. A price based on past sales alone would have left the value of the renovation out of the number.
The pricing
How did we price a home with no comps?
We priced it for what the home was, not only for what had sold nearby. It was a seller’s market, and buyers could not find this level of finish anywhere else in the neighborhood, so we priced well above the neighborhood’s previous high. We listed at $1,399,999.
A price above every past sale only works when buyers see the value for themselves. That is why the launch mattered as much as the number.
The launch
Why did every showing start at the open house?
I launched the home so that all showings began at the open house. Every buyer and every agent who wanted to see it came in at the same time.
More than 100 people came through. Buyers saw the interest for themselves, and their agents knew from the start that they would have to compete. That is what turned traffic into strong offers.
The result
What did the home sell for?
The home closed at $1,550,000. That was $150,000 over the $1,399,999 list price, about $300,000 above the neighborhood’s previous high, and the highest sale in Southridge Lakes at the time.
Why it worked
Why did pricing above every past sale work?
Two things worked together. First, the price reflected the home itself. When a home has no true comps, the past sales in a neighborhood describe a different product, and pricing only from them can leave real money on the table.
Second, the launch created competition. Starting every showing at one open house brought buyers in at the same time, so demand that might have trickled in over weeks showed up all at once.
What would I tell a Southlake seller with a home unlike the others in the neighborhood?
Do not let the neighborhood’s past sales set the ceiling for a home that is not like the others. Start with what makes your home different, then plan how buyers will see it before you settle on the price. The market in June 2023 is not the market today, so we would look at current data together first, and you would have the full picture before you decide.
If you are thinking about selling, read how I prepare, price, and launch a home, or explore Southlake neighborhoods.
Written by Amy Spock, Realtor with SERHANT. I help buyers and sellers in Southlake, Colleyville, and Keller, and people relocating anywhere in the Dallas-Fort Worth metro.
Questions I hear most
Frequently asked questions.
How do you price a home when there are no comparable sales?
Start with what makes the home different, then look at the closest sales available and what they lack. The launch plan matters too, because it decides whether buyers see the value at that price.
Why start all showings at the open house?
It brings buyers in at the same time. When buyers and their agents see the interest firsthand, they know they need to compete, which helps produce strong offers.
Can a home sell for more than anything else in its neighborhood?
Yes, when it offers something earlier sales did not. In Southridge Lakes, a renovation no other home there had matched supported a $1,550,000 sale at a time when no home in the neighborhood had sold above about $1.25 million.
Would the same strategy work in today’s market?
It depends on current inventory and buyer activity. June 2023 was a seller’s market. The price and the launch plan for any home should be based on what the market is doing now.
Begin with a conversation.
Twenty minutes. No pitch. Tell me about your home and your timeline, and you will leave with a clear picture of how I would price and launch it.

